zookeeperInternals.html 24 KB

123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101102103104105106107108109110111112113114115116117118119120121122123124125126127128129130131132133134135136137138139140141142143144145146147148149150151152153154155156157158159160161162163164165166167168169170171172173174175176177178179180181182183184185186187188189190191192193194195196197198199200201202203204205206207208209210211212213214215216217218219220221222223224225226227228229230231232233234235236237238239240241242243244245246247248249250251252253254255256257258259260261262263264265266267268269270271272273274275276277278279280281282283284285286287288289290291292293294295296297298299300301302303304305306307308309310311312313314315316317318319320321322323324325326327328329330331332333334335336337338339340341342343344345346347348349350351352353354355356357358359360361362363364365366367368369370371372373374375376377378379380381382383384385386387388389390391392393394395396397398399400401402403404405406407408409410411412413414415416417418419420421422423424425426427428429430431432433434435436437438439440441442443444445446447448449450451452453454455456457458459460461462463464465466467468469470471472473474475476477478479480481482483484485486487488489490491492493494495496497498499500501502503504505506507508509510511512513514515516517518519520521522523524525526527528529530531532533534535536537538539540541542543544545546547548549550551552553554555556557558559560561562563564565566567568569570571572573574575576577578579580581582583584585586587588589590591592593594595596597598599600601602603604605606607608609610611612613614615616617618619620621622623624625626627628629630631632633634635636637638639640641642643644645646647648649650651652653654655656657658659660661662663664665666667668669670671672673674675676677678679680681682683684685686687688689690691692693694695696697698699700701702703704705706707708709710711712713714715716717718719720721722723724725726727728729730731732733734735736737738739740741
  1. <!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD HTML 4.01 Transitional//EN" "http://www.w3.org/TR/html4/loose.dtd">
  2. <html>
  3. <head>
  4. <META http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=UTF-8">
  5. <meta content="Apache Forrest" name="Generator">
  6. <meta name="Forrest-version" content="0.8">
  7. <meta name="Forrest-skin-name" content="pelt">
  8. <title>ZooKeeper Internals</title>
  9. <link type="text/css" href="skin/basic.css" rel="stylesheet">
  10. <link media="screen" type="text/css" href="skin/screen.css" rel="stylesheet">
  11. <link media="print" type="text/css" href="skin/print.css" rel="stylesheet">
  12. <link type="text/css" href="skin/profile.css" rel="stylesheet">
  13. <script src="skin/getBlank.js" language="javascript" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="skin/getMenu.js" language="javascript" type="text/javascript"></script><script src="skin/fontsize.js" language="javascript" type="text/javascript"></script>
  14. <link rel="shortcut icon" href="images/favicon.ico">
  15. </head>
  16. <body onload="init()">
  17. <script type="text/javascript">ndeSetTextSize();</script>
  18. <div id="top">
  19. <!--+
  20. |breadtrail
  21. +-->
  22. <div class="breadtrail">
  23. <a href="http://www.apache.org/">Apache</a> &gt; <a href="http://hadoop.apache.org/">Hadoop</a> &gt; <a href="http://hadoop.apache.org/zookeeper/">ZooKeeper</a><script src="skin/breadcrumbs.js" language="JavaScript" type="text/javascript"></script>
  24. </div>
  25. <!--+
  26. |header
  27. +-->
  28. <div class="header">
  29. <!--+
  30. |start group logo
  31. +-->
  32. <div class="grouplogo">
  33. <a href="http://hadoop.apache.org/"><img class="logoImage" alt="Hadoop" src="images/hadoop-logo.jpg" title="Apache Hadoop"></a>
  34. </div>
  35. <!--+
  36. |end group logo
  37. +-->
  38. <!--+
  39. |start Project Logo
  40. +-->
  41. <div class="projectlogo">
  42. <a href="http://hadoop.apache.org/zookeeper/"><img class="logoImage" alt="ZooKeeper" src="images/zookeeper_small.gif" title="The Hadoop database"></a>
  43. </div>
  44. <!--+
  45. |end Project Logo
  46. +-->
  47. <!--+
  48. |start Search
  49. +-->
  50. <div class="searchbox">
  51. <form action="http://www.google.com/search" method="get" class="roundtopsmall">
  52. <input value="hadoop.apache.org" name="sitesearch" type="hidden"><input onFocus="getBlank (this, 'Search the site with google');" size="25" name="q" id="query" type="text" value="Search the site with google">&nbsp;
  53. <input name="Search" value="Search" type="submit">
  54. </form>
  55. </div>
  56. <!--+
  57. |end search
  58. +-->
  59. <!--+
  60. |start Tabs
  61. +-->
  62. <ul id="tabs">
  63. <li>
  64. <a class="unselected" href="http://hadoop.apache.org/zookeeper/">Project</a>
  65. </li>
  66. <li>
  67. <a class="unselected" href="http://wiki.apache.org/hadoop/ZooKeeper">Wiki</a>
  68. </li>
  69. <li class="current">
  70. <a class="selected" href="index.html">ZooKeeper Documentation</a>
  71. </li>
  72. </ul>
  73. <!--+
  74. |end Tabs
  75. +-->
  76. </div>
  77. </div>
  78. <div id="main">
  79. <div id="publishedStrip">
  80. <!--+
  81. |start Subtabs
  82. +-->
  83. <div id="level2tabs"></div>
  84. <!--+
  85. |end Endtabs
  86. +-->
  87. <script type="text/javascript"><!--
  88. document.write("Last Published: " + document.lastModified);
  89. // --></script>
  90. </div>
  91. <!--+
  92. |breadtrail
  93. +-->
  94. <div class="breadtrail">
  95. &nbsp;
  96. </div>
  97. <!--+
  98. |start Menu, mainarea
  99. +-->
  100. <!--+
  101. |start Menu
  102. +-->
  103. <div id="menu">
  104. <div onclick="SwitchMenu('menu_1.1', 'skin/')" id="menu_1.1Title" class="menutitle">Overview</div>
  105. <div id="menu_1.1" class="menuitemgroup">
  106. <div class="menuitem">
  107. <a href="index.html">Welcome</a>
  108. </div>
  109. <div class="menuitem">
  110. <a href="zookeeperOver.html">Overview</a>
  111. </div>
  112. <div class="menuitem">
  113. <a href="zookeeperStarted.html">Getting Started</a>
  114. </div>
  115. </div>
  116. <div onclick="SwitchMenu('menu_1.2', 'skin/')" id="menu_1.2Title" class="menutitle">Developer</div>
  117. <div id="menu_1.2" class="menuitemgroup">
  118. <div class="menuitem">
  119. <a href="api/index.html">API Docs</a>
  120. </div>
  121. <div class="menuitem">
  122. <a href="zookeeperProgrammers.html">Programmer's Guide</a>
  123. </div>
  124. <div class="menuitem">
  125. <a href="javaExample.html">Java Example</a>
  126. </div>
  127. <div class="menuitem">
  128. <a href="zookeeperTutorial.html">Barrier and Queue Tutorial</a>
  129. </div>
  130. <div class="menuitem">
  131. <a href="recipes.html">Recipes</a>
  132. </div>
  133. </div>
  134. <div onclick="SwitchMenu('menu_1.3', 'skin/')" id="menu_1.3Title" class="menutitle">Admin &amp; Ops</div>
  135. <div id="menu_1.3" class="menuitemgroup">
  136. <div class="menuitem">
  137. <a href="zookeeperAdmin.html">Administrator's Guide</a>
  138. </div>
  139. </div>
  140. <div onclick="SwitchMenu('menu_selected_1.4', 'skin/')" id="menu_selected_1.4Title" class="menutitle" style="background-image: url('skin/images/chapter_open.gif');">Contributor</div>
  141. <div id="menu_selected_1.4" class="selectedmenuitemgroup" style="display: block;">
  142. <div class="menupage">
  143. <div class="menupagetitle">ZooKeeper Internals</div>
  144. </div>
  145. </div>
  146. <div onclick="SwitchMenu('menu_1.5', 'skin/')" id="menu_1.5Title" class="menutitle">Informal Documentation</div>
  147. <div id="menu_1.5" class="menuitemgroup">
  148. <div class="menuitem">
  149. <a href="http://wiki.apache.org/hadoop/ZooKeeper">Wiki</a>
  150. </div>
  151. <div class="menuitem">
  152. <a href="http://wiki.apache.org/hadoop/ZooKeeper/FAQ">FAQ</a>
  153. </div>
  154. <div class="menuitem">
  155. <a href="http://hadoop.apache.org/zookeeper/mailing_lists.html">Mailing Lists</a>
  156. </div>
  157. <div class="menuitem">
  158. <a href="zookeeperOtherInfo.html">Other Info</a>
  159. </div>
  160. </div>
  161. <div id="credit"></div>
  162. <div id="roundbottom">
  163. <img style="display: none" class="corner" height="15" width="15" alt="" src="skin/images/rc-b-l-15-1body-2menu-3menu.png"></div>
  164. <!--+
  165. |alternative credits
  166. +-->
  167. <div id="credit2"></div>
  168. </div>
  169. <!--+
  170. |end Menu
  171. +-->
  172. <!--+
  173. |start content
  174. +-->
  175. <div id="content">
  176. <div title="Portable Document Format" class="pdflink">
  177. <a class="dida" href="zookeeperInternals.pdf"><img alt="PDF -icon" src="skin/images/pdfdoc.gif" class="skin"><br>
  178. PDF</a>
  179. </div>
  180. <h1>ZooKeeper Internals</h1>
  181. <div id="minitoc-area">
  182. <ul class="minitoc">
  183. <li>
  184. <a href="#ch_Introduction">Introduction</a>
  185. </li>
  186. <li>
  187. <a href="#sc_atomicBroadcast">Atomic Broadcast</a>
  188. <ul class="minitoc">
  189. <li>
  190. <a href="#sc_guaranteesPropertiesDefinitions">Guarantees, Properties, and Definitions</a>
  191. </li>
  192. <li>
  193. <a href="#sc_leaderElection">Leader Activation</a>
  194. </li>
  195. <li>
  196. <a href="#sc_activeMessaging">Active Messaging</a>
  197. </li>
  198. <li>
  199. <a href="#sc_summary">Summary</a>
  200. </li>
  201. <li>
  202. <a href="#sc_comparisons">Comparisons</a>
  203. </li>
  204. </ul>
  205. </li>
  206. <li>
  207. <a href="#sc_logging">Logging</a>
  208. <ul class="minitoc">
  209. <li>
  210. <a href="#sc_developerGuidelines">Developer Guidelines</a>
  211. <ul class="minitoc">
  212. <li>
  213. <a href="#sc_rightLevel">Logging at the Right Level</a>
  214. </li>
  215. <li>
  216. <a href="#sc_log4jIdioms">Use of Standard log4j Idioms</a>
  217. </li>
  218. </ul>
  219. </li>
  220. </ul>
  221. </li>
  222. </ul>
  223. </div>
  224. <a name="N10009"></a><a name="ch_Introduction"></a>
  225. <h2 class="h3">Introduction</h2>
  226. <div class="section">
  227. <p>This document contains information on the inner workings of ZooKeeper.
  228. So far, it discusses these topics:
  229. </p>
  230. <ul>
  231. <li>
  232. <p>
  233. <a href="#sc_atomicBroadcast">Atomic Broadcast</a>
  234. </p>
  235. </li>
  236. <li>
  237. <p>
  238. <a href="#sc_logging">Logging</a>
  239. </p>
  240. </li>
  241. </ul>
  242. </div>
  243. <a name="N10022"></a><a name="sc_atomicBroadcast"></a>
  244. <h2 class="h3">Atomic Broadcast</h2>
  245. <div class="section">
  246. <p>
  247. At the heart of ZooKeeper is an atomic messaging system that keeps all of the servers in sync.</p>
  248. <a name="N1002B"></a><a name="sc_guaranteesPropertiesDefinitions"></a>
  249. <h3 class="h4">Guarantees, Properties, and Definitions</h3>
  250. <p>
  251. The specific guarantees provided by the messaging system used by ZooKeeper are the following:</p>
  252. <dl>
  253. <dt>
  254. <term>
  255. <em>Reliable delivery</em>
  256. </term>
  257. </dt>
  258. <dd>
  259. <p>If a message, m, is delivered
  260. by one server, it will be eventually delivered by all servers.</p>
  261. </dd>
  262. <dt>
  263. <term>
  264. <em>Total order</em>
  265. </term>
  266. </dt>
  267. <dd>
  268. <p> If a message is
  269. delivered before message b by one server, a will be delivered before b by all
  270. servers. If a and b are delivered messages, either a will be delivered before b
  271. or b will be delivered before a.</p>
  272. </dd>
  273. <dt>
  274. <term>
  275. <em>Causal order</em>
  276. </term>
  277. </dt>
  278. <dd>
  279. <p>
  280. If a message b is sent after a message a has been delivered by the sender of b,
  281. a must be ordered before b. If a sender sends c after sending b, c must be ordered after b.
  282. </p>
  283. </dd>
  284. </dl>
  285. <p>
  286. The ZooKeeper messaging system also needs to be efficient, reliable, and easy to
  287. implement and maintain. We make heavy use of messaging, so we need the system to
  288. be able to handle thousands of requests per second. Although we can require at
  289. least k+1 correct servers to send new messages, we must be able to recover from
  290. correlated failures such as power outages. When we implemented the system we had
  291. little time and few engineering resources, so we needed a protocol that is
  292. accessible to engineers and is easy to implement. We found that our protocol
  293. satisfied all of these goals.
  294. </p>
  295. <p>
  296. Our protocol assumes that we can construct point-to-point FIFO channels between
  297. the servers. While similar services usually assume message delivery that can
  298. lose or reorder messages, our assumption of FIFO channels is very practical
  299. given that we use TCP for communication. Specifically we rely on the following property of TCP:</p>
  300. <dl>
  301. <dt>
  302. <term>
  303. <em>Ordered delivery</em>
  304. </term>
  305. </dt>
  306. <dd>
  307. <p>Data is delivered in the same order it is sent and a message m is
  308. delivered only after all messages sent before m have been delivered.
  309. (The corollary to this is that if message m is lost all messages after m will be lost.)</p>
  310. </dd>
  311. <dt>
  312. <term>
  313. <em>No message after close</em>
  314. </term>
  315. </dt>
  316. <dd>
  317. <p>Once a FIFO channel is closed, no messages will be received from it.</p>
  318. </dd>
  319. </dl>
  320. <p>
  321. FLP proved that consensus cannot be achieved in asynchronous distributed systems
  322. if failures are possible. To ensure we achieve consensus in the presence of failures
  323. we use timeouts. However, we rely on times for liveness not for correctness. So,
  324. if timeouts stop working (clocks malfunction for example) the messaging system may
  325. hang, but it will not violate its guarantees.</p>
  326. <p>When describing the ZooKeeper messaging protocol we will talk of packets,
  327. proposals, and messages:</p>
  328. <dl>
  329. <dt>
  330. <term>
  331. <em>Packet</em>
  332. </term>
  333. </dt>
  334. <dd>
  335. <p>a sequence of bytes sent through a FIFO channel</p>
  336. </dd>
  337. <dt>
  338. <term>
  339. <em>Proposal</em>
  340. </term>
  341. </dt>
  342. <dd>
  343. <p>a unit of agreement. Proposals are agreed upon by exchanging packets
  344. with a quorum of ZooKeeper servers. Most proposals contain messages, however the
  345. NEW_LEADER proposal is an example of a proposal that does not correspond to a message.</p>
  346. </dd>
  347. <dt>
  348. <term>
  349. <em>Message</em>
  350. </term>
  351. </dt>
  352. <dd>
  353. <p>a sequence of bytes to be atomically broadcast to all ZooKeeper
  354. servers. A message put into a proposal and agreed upon before it is delivered.</p>
  355. </dd>
  356. </dl>
  357. <p>
  358. As stated above, ZooKeeper guarantees a total order of messages, and it also
  359. guarantees a total order of proposals. ZooKeeper exposes the total ordering using
  360. a ZooKeeper transaction id (<em>zxid</em>). All proposals will be stamped with a zxid when
  361. it is proposed and exactly reflects the total ordering. Proposals are sent to all
  362. ZooKeeper servers and committed when a quorum of them acknowledge the proposal.
  363. If a proposal contains a message, the message will be delivered when the proposal
  364. is committed. Acknowledgement means the server has recorded the proposal to persistent storage.
  365. Our quorums have the requirement that any pair of quorum must have at least one server
  366. in common. We ensure this by requiring that all quorums have size (<em>n/2+1</em>) where
  367. n is the number of servers that make up a ZooKeeper service.
  368. </p>
  369. <p>
  370. The zxid has two parts: the epoch and a counter. In our implementation the zxid
  371. is a 64-bit number. We use the high order 32-bits for the epoch and the low order
  372. 32-bits for the counter. Because it has two parts represent the zxid both as a
  373. number and as a pair of integers, (<em>epoch, count</em>). The epoch number represents a
  374. change in leadership. Each time a new leader comes into power it will have its
  375. own epoch number. We have a simple algorithm to assign a unique zxid to a proposal:
  376. the leader simply increments the zxid to obtain a unique zxid for each proposal.
  377. <em>Leadership activation will ensure that only one leader uses a given epoch, so our
  378. simple algorithm guarantees that every proposal will have a unique id.</em>
  379. </p>
  380. <p>
  381. ZooKeeper messaging consists of two phases:</p>
  382. <dl>
  383. <dt>
  384. <term>
  385. <em>Leader activation</em>
  386. </term>
  387. </dt>
  388. <dd>
  389. <p>In this phase a leader establishes the correct state of the system
  390. and gets ready to start making proposals.</p>
  391. </dd>
  392. <dt>
  393. <term>
  394. <em>Active messaging</em>
  395. </term>
  396. </dt>
  397. <dd>
  398. <p>In this phase a leader accepts messages to propose and coordinates message delivery.</p>
  399. </dd>
  400. </dl>
  401. <p>
  402. ZooKeeper is a holistic protocol. We do not focus on individual proposals, rather
  403. look at the stream of proposals as a whole. Our strict ordering allows us to do this
  404. efficiently and greatly simplifies our protocol. Leadership activation embodies
  405. this holistic concept. A leader becomes active only when a quorum of followers
  406. (The leader counts as a follower as well. You can always vote for yourself ) has synced
  407. up with the leader, they have the same state. This state consists of all of the
  408. proposals that the leader believes have been committed and the proposal to follow
  409. the leader, the NEW_LEADER proposal. (Hopefully you are thinking to
  410. yourself, <em>Does the set of proposals that the leader believes has been committed
  411. included all the proposals that really have been committed?</em> The answer is <em>yes</em>.
  412. Below, we make clear why.)
  413. </p>
  414. <a name="N100B9"></a><a name="sc_leaderElection"></a>
  415. <h3 class="h4">Leader Activation</h3>
  416. <p>
  417. Leader activation includes leader election. We currently have two leader election
  418. algorithms in ZooKeeper: LeaderElection and FastLeaderElection (AuthFastLeaderElection
  419. is a variant of FastLeaderElection). ZooKeeper messaging doesn't care about the
  420. exact method of electing a leader has long as the following holds:
  421. </p>
  422. <ul>
  423. <li>
  424. <p>The leader has seen the highest zxid of all the followers.</p>
  425. </li>
  426. <li>
  427. <p>A quorum of servers have committed to following the leader.</p>
  428. </li>
  429. </ul>
  430. <p>
  431. Of these two requirements only the first, the highest zxid amoung the followers
  432. needs to hold for correct operation. The second requirement, a quorum of followers,
  433. just needs to hold with high probability. We are going to recheck the second requirement,
  434. so if a failure happens during or after the leader election and quorum is lost,
  435. we will recover by abandoning leader activation and running another election.
  436. </p>
  437. <p>
  438. After leader election a single server will be designated as a leader and start
  439. waiting for followers to connect. The rest of the servers will try to connect to
  440. the leader. The leader will sync up with followers by sending any proposals they
  441. are missing, or if a follower is missing too many proposals, it will send a full
  442. snapshot of the state to the follower.
  443. </p>
  444. <p>
  445. There is a corner cases that a follower arrives that has proposals, U, not seen
  446. by a leader. Proposals are seen in order, so the proposals of U will have a zxids
  447. higher than zxids seen by the leader. The follower must have arrived after the
  448. leader election, otherwise the follower would have been elected leader given that
  449. it has seen a higher zxid. Since committed proposals must be seen by a quorum of
  450. servers, and a quorum of servers that elected the leader did not see U, the proposals
  451. of you have not been committed, so they can be discarded. When the follower connects
  452. to the leader, the leader will tell the follower to discard U.
  453. </p>
  454. <p>
  455. A new leader establishes a zxid to start using for new proposals by getting the
  456. epoch, e, of the highest zxid it has seen and setting the next zxid to use to be
  457. (e+1, 0), fter the leader syncs with a follower, it will propose a NEW_LEADER
  458. proposal. Once the NEW_LEADER proposal has been committed, the leader will activate
  459. and start receiving and issuing proposals.
  460. </p>
  461. <p>
  462. It all sounds complicated but here are the basic rules of operation during leader
  463. activation:
  464. </p>
  465. <ul>
  466. <li>
  467. <p>A follower will ACK the NEW_LEADER proposal after it has synced with the leader.</p>
  468. </li>
  469. <li>
  470. <p>A follower will only ACK a NEW_LEADER proposal with a given zxid from a single server.</p>
  471. </li>
  472. <li>
  473. <p>A new leader will COMMIT the NEW_LEADER proposal when a quorum of followers have ACKed it.</p>
  474. </li>
  475. <li>
  476. <p>A follower will commit any state it received from the leader when the NEW_LEADER proposal is COMMIT.</p>
  477. </li>
  478. <li>
  479. <p>A new leader will not accept new proposals until the NEW_LEADER proposal has been COMMITED.</p>
  480. </li>
  481. </ul>
  482. <p>
  483. If leader election terminates erroneously, we don't have a problem since the
  484. NEW_LEADER proposal will not be committed since the leader will not have quorum.
  485. When this happens, the leader and any remaining followers will timeout and go back
  486. to leader election.
  487. </p>
  488. <a name="N100F7"></a><a name="sc_activeMessaging"></a>
  489. <h3 class="h4">Active Messaging</h3>
  490. <p>
  491. Leader Activation does all the heavy lifting. Once the leader is coronated he can
  492. start blasting out proposals. As long as he remains the leader no other leader can
  493. emerge since no other leader will be able to get a quorum of followers. If a new
  494. leader does emerge,
  495. it means that the leader has lost quorum, and the new leader will clean up any
  496. mess left over during her leadership activation.
  497. </p>
  498. <p>ZooKeeper messaging operates similar to a classic two-phase commit.</p>
  499. <img alt="" src="images/2pc.png"><p>
  500. All communication channels are FIFO, so everything is done in order. Specifically
  501. the following operating constraints are observed:</p>
  502. <ul>
  503. <li>
  504. <p>The leader sends proposals to all followers using
  505. the same order. Moreover, this order follows the order in which requests have been
  506. received. Because we use FIFO channels this means that followers also receive proposals in order.
  507. </p>
  508. </li>
  509. <li>
  510. <p>Followers process messages in the order they are received. This
  511. means that messages will be ACKed in order and the leader will receive ACKs from
  512. followers in order, due to the FIFO channels. It also means that if message $m$
  513. has been written to non-volatile storage, all messages that were proposed before
  514. $m$ have been written to non-volatile storage.</p>
  515. </li>
  516. <li>
  517. <p>The leader will issue a COMMIT to all followers as soon as a
  518. quorum of followers have ACKed a message. Since messages are ACKed in order,
  519. COMMITs will be sent by the leader as received by the followers in order.</p>
  520. </li>
  521. <li>
  522. <p>COMMITs are processed in order. Followers deliver a proposals
  523. message when that proposal is committed.</p>
  524. </li>
  525. </ul>
  526. <a name="N1011E"></a><a name="sc_summary"></a>
  527. <h3 class="h4">Summary</h3>
  528. <p>So there you go. Why does it work? Specifically, why does is set of proposals
  529. believed by a new leader always contain any proposal that has actually been committed?
  530. First, all proposals have a unique zxid, so unlike other protocols, we never have
  531. to worry about two different values being proposed for the same zxid; followers
  532. (a leader is also a follower) see and record proposals in order; proposals are
  533. committed in order; there is only one active leader at a time since followers only
  534. follow a single leader at a time; a new leader has seen all committed proposals
  535. from the previous epoch since it has seen the highest zxid from a quorum of servers;
  536. any uncommited proposals from a previous epoch seen by a new leader will be committed
  537. by that leader before it becomes active.</p>
  538. <a name="N10127"></a><a name="sc_comparisons"></a>
  539. <h3 class="h4">Comparisons</h3>
  540. <p>
  541. Isn't this just Multi-Paxos? No, Multi-Paxos requires some way of assuring that
  542. there is only a single coordinator. We do not count on such assurances. Instead
  543. we use the leader activation to recover from leadership change or old leaders
  544. believing they are still active.
  545. </p>
  546. <p>
  547. Isn't this just Paxos? Your active messaging phase looks just like phase 2 of Paxos?
  548. Actually, to us active messaging looks just like 2 phase commit without the need to
  549. handle aborts. Active messaging is different from both in the sense that it has
  550. cross proposal ordering requirements. If we do not maintain strict FIFO ordering of
  551. all packets, it all falls apart. Also, our leader activation phase is different from
  552. both of them. In particular, our use of epochs allows us to skip blocks of uncommitted
  553. proposals and to not worry about duplicate proposals for a given zxid.
  554. </p>
  555. </div>
  556. <a name="N10134"></a><a name="sc_logging"></a>
  557. <h2 class="h3">Logging</h2>
  558. <div class="section">
  559. <p>
  560. ZooKeeper uses
  561. <a href="http://logging.apache.org/log4j">log4j</a>
  562. version 1.2 as its logging infrastructure. For information on configuring log4j for
  563. ZooKeeper, see the <a href="zookeeperAdmin.html#sc_logging">Logging</a> section
  564. of the <a href="zookeeperAdmin.html">ZooKeeper Administrator's Guide.</a>
  565. </p>
  566. <a name="N10149"></a><a name="sc_developerGuidelines"></a>
  567. <h3 class="h4">Developer Guidelines</h3>
  568. <p>Please follow these guidelines when submitting code. Patch reviewers will look for the following:</p>
  569. <a name="N10151"></a><a name="sc_rightLevel"></a>
  570. <h4>Logging at the Right Level</h4>
  571. <p>
  572. There are <a href="http://logging.apache.org/log4j/1.2/apidocs/org/apache/log4j/Level.html#FATAL">6 levels of logging in log4j</a>.
  573. It's important to pick the right one. In order of higher to lower severity:</p>
  574. <ol>
  575. <li>
  576. <p> FATAL level designates very severe error events that will presumably lead the application to abort</p>
  577. </li>
  578. <li>
  579. <p>ERROR level designates error events that might still allow the application to continue running.</p>
  580. </li>
  581. <li>
  582. <p>WARN level designates potentially harmful situations.</p>
  583. </li>
  584. <li>
  585. <p>INFO level designates informational messages that highlight the progress of the application at coarse-grained level.</p>
  586. </li>
  587. <li>
  588. <p>EBUG Level designates fine-grained informational events that are most useful to debug an application.</p>
  589. </li>
  590. <li>
  591. <p>TRACE Level designates finer-grained informational events than the DEBUG.</p>
  592. </li>
  593. </ol>
  594. <p>
  595. ZooKeeper is typically run in production such that log messages of INFO level
  596. severity and higher (more severe) are output to the log.</p>
  597. <a name="N1017C"></a><a name="sc_log4jIdioms"></a>
  598. <h4>Use of Standard log4j Idioms</h4>
  599. <p>
  600. <em>Static Message Logging</em>
  601. </p>
  602. <pre class="code">
  603. LOG.debug("process completed successfully!");
  604. </pre>
  605. <p>However when creating a message from a number of components (string
  606. concatenation), the log call should be wrapped with a "isXEnabled()" call. this
  607. eliminates the string concatenation overhead when debug level logging is not enabled.
  608. </p>
  609. <pre class="code">
  610. if (LOG.isDebugEnabled()) {
  611. LOG.debug("got " + count + " messages in " + time + " minutes");
  612. }
  613. </pre>
  614. <p>
  615. <em>Naming</em>
  616. </p>
  617. <p>
  618. Loggers should be named after the class in which they are used. (See the
  619. <a href="http://logging.apache.org/log4j/1.2/faq.html#2.4">log4j faq</a>
  620. for reasons why this is a good idea.)
  621. </p>
  622. <pre class="code">
  623. public class Foo {
  624. private static final Logger LOG = Logger.getLogger(Foo.class);
  625. ....
  626. public Foo() {
  627. LOG.info("constructing Foo");
  628. </pre>
  629. <p>
  630. <em>Exception handling</em>
  631. </p>
  632. <pre class="code">
  633. try {
  634. // code
  635. } catch (XYZException e) {
  636. // do this
  637. LOG.error("Something bad happened", e);
  638. // don't do this (generally)
  639. // LOG.error(e);
  640. // why? because "don't do" case hides the stack trace
  641. // continue process here as you need... recover or (re)throw
  642. }
  643. </pre>
  644. </div>
  645. <p align="right">
  646. <font size="-2"></font>
  647. </p>
  648. </div>
  649. <!--+
  650. |end content
  651. +-->
  652. <div class="clearboth">&nbsp;</div>
  653. </div>
  654. <div id="footer">
  655. <!--+
  656. |start bottomstrip
  657. +-->
  658. <div class="lastmodified">
  659. <script type="text/javascript"><!--
  660. document.write("Last Published: " + document.lastModified);
  661. // --></script>
  662. </div>
  663. <div class="copyright">
  664. Copyright &copy;
  665. 2008 <a href="http://www.apache.org/licenses/">The Apache Software Foundation.</a>
  666. </div>
  667. <!--+
  668. |end bottomstrip
  669. +-->
  670. </div>
  671. </body>
  672. </html>